Library: When to use subcritical water extraction?

When to use subcritical water extraction?

Supercritical CO₂ dissolves non-polar compounds. Terpenes, fatty acids, and carnosic acid are extracted with CO₂. Polar polyphenols like rosmarinic acid, chlorogenic acid, and catechins do not dissolve in CO₂. Subcritical water extraction (SWE) extracts these compounds. Under high temperature and pressure, water becomes less polar. Polar compounds are extracted without organic solvents.

What is subcritical water?

Water stays liquid above 100°C under sufficient pressure. Its dielectric constant decreases under these conditions. Water behaves like methanol or ethanol. Between 150–200°C, water can even dissolve non-polar compounds [1].

This adjustable polarity allows SWE to extract different compounds at different temperatures. Polar compounds are extracted at lower temperatures. Less polar compounds are extracted at higher temperatures. Different fractions can be obtained from the same plant at different temperatures.

Which compounds are extracted with SWE?

Polar polyphenols are effectively extracted with SWE:

  • Rosmarinic acid (rosemary, lemon balm, sage)
  • Chlorogenic acid (coffee, artichoke)
  • Catechins (green tea)
  • Phenolic acids (ferulic, caffeic, coumaric)

In a study on lemon balm (Melissa officinalis), SWE at 100°C yielded rosmarinic acid as effectively as 50% ethanol [2]. When the temperature was raised to 150°C, rosmarinic acid content decreased by 20%. Higher temperature is not always better due to thermal degradation.

Comparison of CO₂ and SWE

Rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis) is an example to compare these two methods. Rosemary contains two main antioxidants: carnosic acid (non-polar) and rosmarinic acid (polar).

MethodTarget compoundAdvantage
Supercritical CO₂Carnosic acidHigh purity, food antioxidant (E392)
Subcritical waterRosmarinic acidNo organic solvent, low cost

In a separation study, carnosic acid and rosmarinic acid were selectively separated from rosemary extract. Solid phase extraction (SPE) yielded 76.5% purity for carnosic acid. Liquid-liquid extraction yielded 56.3% purity for rosmarinic acid [3].

Optimal temperature range

Temperature is the most critical parameter in SWE. The 100–150°C range is considered optimal for phenolic compounds [1].

Low temperature (100-120°C): Suitable for thermally sensitive compounds (rosmarinic acid, anthocyanins). The highest rosmarinic acid yield in lemon balm was obtained at 100°C [2].

Medium temperature (130-160°C): Polyphenol yield increases, but degradation also begins. In polyphenol extraction from grape pomace, 120°C was optimal. At this temperature, a 1.5-fold higher yield was obtained compared to conventional extraction [4].

High temperature (>160°C): Cellulose and hemicellulose dissolve. Plant cell walls break down. Thermal degradation of phenolic compounds accelerates.

No organic solvent used

SWE does not require organic solvents. Water is non-toxic. There is no solvent residue issue after extraction [1].

In some applications, a small amount of ethanol is added as a co-solvent. In polyphenol extraction from grape pomace, a 50% ethanol-water mixture gave higher yields than pure water [4]. Even in this case, the amount of ethanol is much lower than in conventional solvent extraction.

References

  1. Cheng Y, Xue F et al. Subcritical Water Extraction of Natural Products. Molecules 2021. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules26134004
  2. Atanasova A, Petrova A et al. Subcritical Water Extraction of Rosmarinic Acid from Lemon Balm and Its Effect on Plant Cell Wall Constituents. Antioxidants 2023. https://doi.org/10.3390/antiox12040888
  3. Zhu C, Fan Y et al. The Selective Separation of Carnosic Acid and Rosmarinic Acid by Solid-Phase Extraction and Liquid–Liquid Extraction. Molecules 2023. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules28145493
  4. Natolino A, Passaghe P et al. Intensification of grape marc exploitation by subcritical water-ethanol extraction. Journal of Food Engineering 2024. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2024.112185