Library: Same plant, why is the extract different?

Same plant, why is the extract different?

Two extracts from the same plant can differ. This is not a quality defect. It is the nature of the plant. Extract composition depends on four variables: chemotype, harvest time, drying method, and particle size during extraction.

What is a chemotype?

Plants of the same species can produce different main components, even if they look identical. This genetic difference is called a chemotype.

Oregano example. Turkish oregano (Origanum onites) is a carvacrol-dominant chemotype. In one study, carvacrol content in oregano essential oil from different regions of Turkey varied between 48% and 74% [1]. Other chemotypes of the same species can be dominant in thymol, p-cymene, or gamma-terpinene.

Mint example. One chemotype of Mentha longifolia collected from Iran was found to be carvone-dominant (62%). Other chemotypes of the same species contain pulegone or piperitone [2].

Chemotype starts with seed selection and can be kept constant during cultivation. The chemotype of a purchased extract is read from the technical data sheet and certificate of analysis.

Does harvest time change the composition?

Harvest time affects both total oil yield and the ratio of individual components.

Oregano. A study on Turkish oregano compared three harvest stages: vegetative (leaf growth), pre-flowering, and full flowering. Essential oil yield was 1.6% at the vegetative stage and 3.5% at full flowering. The carvacrol ratio increased from 44% at the vegetative stage to 78% at full flowering [1]. Antioxidant capacity was also highest at the flowering stage.

Sage. In sage (Salvia officinalis) grown in Italy, harvest date affected both yield and thujone content. Early harvest resulted in low yield. Late harvest increased the thujone ratio [3].

Mint. A 2023 study examined mint harvest time and distillation time together. Harvest time affected menthol and menthone ratios. Antioxidant activity varied accordingly [4].

Conclusion. Plants from the same field and seed yield different profiles when harvested in different weeks. Therefore, a certificate of analysis is issued separately for each lot.

Does the drying method make a difference?

Fresh and dried plants do not contain the same components. During drying, some volatile components evaporate and some are converted.

Oregano. A study on Italian oregano (Origanum vulgare) compared four drying methods: shade, sun, hot air (40 °C), and oven (60 °C). Essential oil yield was 1.5% with sun drying and 2.1% with shade drying. The carvacrol ratio varied between 58% and 72% among methods [5].

Basil. Shade drying preserved the linalool ratio in basil. Hot air drying lowered the ratio [6].

Garlic. The drying method changed the ratio of diallyl sulfide compounds in garlic essential oil. Freeze drying (lyophilization) provided the highest preservation [7].

Conclusion. Low temperature and controlled airflow preserve volatile components better. Hot and rapid drying can cause yield loss. The supplier can state the drying method. The profile on the certificate of analysis can be compared with expected values.

Why does particle size matter?

Supercritical CO₂ extraction starts with grinding the raw material. Particle size directly affects extraction efficiency.

Principle. Small particles provide a larger surface area. Solvent (CO₂) reaches target components more easily. But very fine grinding causes pressure drop and slows the flow.

Bilberry. For anthocyanin extraction from bilberry press cake, particle size and drying method were studied together. Smaller particles gave a higher anthocyanin yield [8].

Grapevine leaf. In a study on grapevine leaves, medium-sized particles (0.5–1 mm) optimized both yield and selectivity. Mass transfer resistance increased in very fine particles [9].

Paprika. A pilot-scale study for carotenoid extraction from sweet paprika showed that particle size and moisture content must be optimized together [10].

Conclusion. Particle size is set at the production facility. As a buyer, you cannot change it. The result appears on the certificate of analysis: same raw material, different grinding, different yield and purity.

What to check on the certificate?

Variation in composition is normal. Documentation of each lot is what matters.

  • Certificate of analysis (CoA) reports the actual composition of that lot. It is compared against the specification range.
  • Technical data sheet (TDS) describes general product properties and specification ranges. The TDS can include raw material source, drying method, or particle size.
  • Lot number identifies a product group made under identical conditions. Each lot has its own CoA.

Different lots of the same product can differ, even within specification. If a formulation targets a specific ratio, lot selection or blending can be used.


References

[1] Ozkan G., Baydar H., Erbas S. (2010). The influence of harvest time on essential oil composition, phenolic constituents and antioxidant properties of Turkish oregano (Origanum onites L.). Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 90(2), 205–209. https://doi.org/10.1002/jsfa.3788

[2] Monfared A., Nabid M., Rustaiyan A. (2002). Composition of a carvone chemotype of Mentha longifolia (L.) Huds. from Iran. Journal of Essential Oil Research, 14(1), 51–52. https://doi.org/10.1080/10412905.2002.9699761

[3] Piccaglia R., Marotti M., Dellacecca V. (1997). Effect of planting density and harvest date on yield and chemical composition of sage oil. Journal of Essential Oil Research, 9(2), 187–191. https://doi.org/10.1080/10412905.1997.9699457

[4] Marques S., Pinheiro R., Silva R. et al. (2023). Effects of harvest time and hydrodistillation time on yield, composition, and antioxidant activity of mint essential oil. Molecules, 28(22), 7583. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules28227583

[5] Caputo L., Amato G., De Martino L. et al. (2022). Impact of drying methods on the yield and chemistry of Origanum vulgare L. essential oil. Scientific Reports, 12, 3218. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-07841-w

[6] Hassanpouraghdam M., Hassani A., Vojodi L. et al. (2010). Drying method affects essential oil content and composition of basil (Ocimum basilicum L.). Journal of Essential Oil Bearing Plants, 13(6), 759–766. https://doi.org/10.1080/0972060x.2010.10643892

[7] Dziri S., Casabianca H., Hanchi B. et al. (2014). Composition of garlic essential oil (Allium sativum L.) as influenced by drying method. Journal of Essential Oil Research, 26(2), 91–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/10412905.2013.868329

[8] Eliasson L., Labrosse L., Ahrné L. (2017). Effect of drying technique and particle size of bilberry press cake on the extraction efficiency of anthocyanins by pressurized carbon dioxide extraction. LWT - Food Science and Technology, 85, 510–516. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lwt.2017.03.030

[9] de Melo M., Carius B., Simões M. et al. (2020). Supercritical CO₂ extraction of V. vinifera leaves: Influence of cosolvents and particle size on removal kinetics and selectivity to target compounds. The Journal of Supercritical Fluids, 165, 104959. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.supflu.2020.104959

[10] Kostrzewa D., Dobrzyńska-Inger A., Turczyn A. et al. (2021). Pilot scale supercritical CO₂ extraction of carotenoids from sweet paprika (Capsicum annuum L.): Influence of particle size and moisture content of plant material. LWT, 135, 110345. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lwt.2020.110345